☰ Menu
bible.lockman.org  Home | Search
 
  • Lockman.org
  • About Us

    • About
    • Who we are
    • History
    • Who is Jesus?
    •  
  • Shop / Catalog

    • Digital
    • NASB 2020
    • NASB 1995
    • NASB 1977
    • Amplified
    • NBLA (Spanish)
    • LBLA (Spanish)
    •  
  • NASB

    • NASB
    • Amplified
    • LBLA
    • NBLA
    • Permissions
    •  
Click Here
Bibles by the Case, with free shipping
All New NASB 2020 - 44% off
Save 40% or more on Bibles now! Limited quantities

Questions, answers, or notes on a Bible verse:
(i.e. Gen 1:1)
Read the Bible:
Book Chap:verse
New Window
Translation: Search Range: Search word(s):


Search for your Bible question and answer here:


Matthew

SCROLL TO BOTTOM FOR CONTENT THREADS.
Prior Book | Prior Chapter | Prior Verse | Next Verse | Next Chapter | Next Book | Viewing NASB and Amplified 2015
NASB Matthew 1:25 but kept her a virgin until she gave birth to a Son; and he called His name Jesus.
AMPLIFIED 2015 Matthew 1:25 but he kept her a virgin until she had given birth to a Son [her firstborn child]; and he named Him Jesus (The LORD is salvation).
SCROLL TO BOTTOM FOR CONTENT THREADS.
Bible Question (short): Was Mary a virgin her whole life

Question (full): srbaegon: You are trying to use english grammatical rules with greek text, but english and greek grammar are very different creatures. Also regarding John 7:5, if they were Mary's children they would have had the responsibility of looking after their mother whether they believed in Jesus or not. Quite clearly however, they did believe after Jesus' resurrection, look at Acts 1:14. So if they were Mary's children there is absolutely no reason for Jesus entrust his mother to John. They are not Mary's children which is why Jesus does so.

Lionstrong: It make make perfect sense to you in English, but in Greek the opposite meaning is clear.

Hank: I gave a subjective opinion of mine as a follow on from the points I had made, perhaps that was a mistake. The points, however, stand on their own and are not the result of my opinion. I would ask you to consider why Mary and Joseph got married at all, since Joseph was not the father of Jesus. However, if Mary was to have a child with no apparent father, all would have assumed that she had commited adultery and as a consequence she would have been stoned to death. Thus Joseph was necessary to give the semblance of fatherhood to Mary's child in order to protect her reputation and life. It does not automatically follow that they had sexual relations as a normal husband and wife. I think it is an understatement to say that they were far from a normal husband and wife. You again quote Matt 1:25 and state that my "translation" goes against every reliable translation that exists in English. I'm not giving you a translation though, I am telling you what is says in Greek. Unfortunately, all literal translations of the text in English miss this point because we read with English grammar and not with Greek. I will quote other passages below to illustrate this point.
Also, there is no mention of other children early on in Jesus life. In Luke 2:41 it tells how Mary and Joseph went every year to Jerusalem for the Feast of the Passover. When Jesus was twelve years old and they were returning home, Jesus had stayed at the temple without them being aware of it. They assumed he was with friends or "relatives" in their company and travelled a day before going back to search for him. Note that this is twelve years after their marriage and there is only Joseph, Mary and Jesus, plus their relatives. There is no mention of other children.

Psalm 72:7 "In his days the righteous will flourish;prosperity will abound till the moon is no more."
Does this mean that when the moon is no more the righteous will no longer flourish?

1 Corinthians 15:25 "For he must reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet."
Does this mean that Christ will no longer reign after all his enemies are put under his feet?

Psalm 123:2 "As the eyes of slaves look to the hand of their master, as the eyes of a maid look to the hand of her mistress, so our eyes look to the Lord our God, till he shows us his mercy."
So when God shows us his mercy, we no longer look to the Lord our God?

Matthew 28:18-20 Then Jesus came to them and said, "All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to (eos/until) the very end of the age."
Again, does this mean that at the end of the age Jesus will leave us?

The answer to all the above is no, the conditions are not bound by the events but rather are ongoing, eternal. The whole point of Matthew 1:25 is to state clearly that Joseph and Mary did not have sexual relations. In Greek it is clearly understood to mean this, there is no ambiguity. That is the "plain reading of the text" in Greek and all mention of Jesus' brothers and sisters in the scriptures must be understood in the light of this fact.

  Up   |    Down     View Branch    ID# 47584  
 Questions and/or Subjects for Matt 1:25   Author 
 Was Mary a virgin her whole life (?)
  dstone
 The Amplified Version of Matthew 1:25 sa...
  Mommapbs
 Many quote Matthew 1:25 as clearly stati...
  jawz
 Hello jawz You say: "The greek word ...
  srbaegon
 Dear jawz, You write, "If you read ...
  Lionstrong
 Jawz, your reasoning is flawed because i...
  Hank
 Did Mary and Joseph marry? (?)
  jawz
 Jawz, you say I make a big deal about th...
  Hank
 Christ born out of wedlock? (?)
  Amber_G
 Scripture ... Isa 7:14, Mat 1:23, Luk 1:...
  Searcher56
 Searcher- No, I realize that Mary was p...
  Amber_G
 Betrothal was legally binding. It was ma...
  jawz
 Greetings! You wrote, "if Mary had othe...
  Mommapbs
 Mommapbs, to your statement, "I respect...
  Hank
 Greetings Hank and a sincere than you fo...
  Mommapbs
 Mommapbs, at your bidding I read your po...
  Hank
 Greetings Hank! Thanks for the informati...
  Mommapbs
 Hi Mommapbs, I haven't considered or re...
  Ray
 Greetings Ray! Thanks for your reply!How...
  Mommapbs
 Was Mary a virgin her whole life (?)
  jawz
 Jawz, I haven't been on the forum for ...
  chris a
 You would do well to question my scholar...
  jawz
 Jawz, I see your point about the imperf...
  chris a
 Greetings Chris! Good observations!  ...
  Morant61
 Hi, Tim!  You know, one of the things th...
  Hank
 Hello Hank Over the years I've brist...
  srbaegon
 Steve, should it become necessary for yo...
  Hank
 I would rather be treated by someone who...
  jawz
 Greetings Jawz! Would you mind provid...
  Morant61
 It is rather the absence of anything to ...
  jawz
 Greetings Jawz! An argument from sile...
  Morant61
 Married to a beautiful Greek woman and c...
  jawz
 Greetings Jawz! Aren't all Greek wom...
  Morant61
 Greetings Jawz! I have been searching...
  Morant61
 I think you will find that it is almost ...
  jawz
 Greetings Jawz! You are correct that ...
  Morant61
 If you will look at Matt 1:25 you will s...
  meusing
 Hello jawz You are trying to apply lo...
  srbaegon
 Hi Steve,  Jawz will not disagree with y...
  Ray
 Steve, I apologise. Your response to my ...
  jawz
 Greetings Jawz! Might I ask how much ...
  Morant61
 Greetings Tim! I'm reasonably fluent i...
  jawz
 Greetings Jawz! Thanks for the respon...
  Morant61
 Jawz, you ask me to consider why Mary an...
  Hank
 I would hardly call it overwhelming cont...
  jawz
 Hello jawz You wrote: "yet the Jewis...
  srbaegon
 Greetings Jawz! You wrote:   "We ...
  Morant61
 Part IV  MARY -- HONOR OR ADORATION?  ...
  kalos
 This James (the Lord's brother) is one ...
  jawz
 Part I MARY--HONOR OR ADORATION?  'I...
  kalos
 Part II  MARY -- HONOR OR ADORATION?  ...
  kalos
 I'm not Roman Catholic, but this intrig...
  jawz
 Jawz, you state that you are not a Roman...
  Hank
 Raised in the Anglican church of Austral...
  jawz
 You wrote: "I do not subscribe to so...
  Reformer Joe
 joe I'm not trying to be argumentive...
  Brian.g
 Brian: "I have always agreed that Sc...
  Reformer Joe
 You wrote: "Last, for many, many yea...
  Reformer Joe
 Joe A passing thought, not meant to b...
  Brian.g
 I will be happy to address denominationa...
  Reformer Joe
 Joe I don't know the answer to your ...
  Brian.g
 It is not the church we go to that saves...
  meusing
 Greetings Brian! You wrote: "And,...
  Morant61
 "I don't know the answer to your quest...
  Reformer Joe
 OK Joe, Let's narrow the field from ...
  Brian.g
 Brian, if your object is to show that th...
  Hank
 Hank, Your story about the Immaculate C...
  Emmaus
 Emmaus, thank you for your decorous rema...
  Hank
 Well, if you do not know by now what pos...
  Reformer Joe
 Hi Joe! LOL  ;-) Your Brother in C...
  Morant61
 Well at all events, Joe, your user scree...
  Hank
 Greetings Brian! Much is made about t...
  Morant61
 Tim Pleasure hearing from you. The...
  Brian.g
 Greetings Brian! I think you missed m...
  Morant61
 Tim As an example, we see numerous in...
  Brian.g
 Greetings Brian! Like I said, each de...
  Morant61
 Brian, you ask "What authority do Prote...
  Hank
 Part III  MARY -- HONOR OR ADORATION?  ...
  kalos
 Wholehearted agreement here. The Roman C...
  jawz
 jawz I've always understood Romans 5...
  Brian.g
 Brian is right on Romans: "For as th...
  Reformer Joe
 kalos Do you feel that God, the Fathe...
  Brian.g
 Where is the TRUTH found? (?)
  Mommapbs
 Mommapbs The role of a church is to h...
  Brian.g
 Brian: You wrote: "The role of a ...
  Reformer Joe
 Joe By proclaiming the excellencies o...
  Brian.g
 Brian, you wrote,"I trust the teachings...
  Mommapbs
 Mommapbs Do you trust your pastor and...
  Brian.g
 You asked, "Do you trust your pastor an...
  Mommapbs
 Mommapbs I am not trying to be rude o...
  Brian.g
 I "kinda" knew you'd ask me this! Sim...
  Mommapbs
 Mommapbs Are you active in your church ...
  Brian.g
 Dear Brian - I have served the Lord in m...
  Mommapbs
 How right you are! Thank you, I've enj...
  Brian.g
 Greetings Jawz! My brother, you are c...
  Morant61
 You are indeed correct and you will noti...
  jawz
 Part V  MARY -- HONOR OR ADORATION?  ...
  kalos
 Brothers of Jesus? Final proof! Ok, I...
  jawz
 Hi jawz, You speak about being "pretty ...
  Ray
 Ray, I assume that you are saying that t...
  jawz
 See Matt 12:46 and Mark 6:3. In Matt 12:...
  kalos
 quote: "MATTHEW EXPLICITLY CONNECTS THE...
  jawz
 dstone, Gospel references to the "br...
  Emmaus
 Hi Emmaus, Would you like to comment on ...
  Ray
 Ray, In this context the local Church i...
  Emmaus
 Is Mary still a virgin. (?)
  arizona
 Does Joseph, our Lord's stepfather speak (?)
  Renovate Me
 Did Mary remain a virgin? (?)
  Krisjen
 Until (?)
  Dalcent
 Why is firstborn missing from Matt 1:25 (?)
  Chuck 1944
 Jesus' lineage not of Abraham? (?)
  CuriousAboutJesus




bible.lockman.org
Answered Bible Questions
Primary Bible Questions (?)
Bible verses
About StudyBibleForum.com

The Lockman Foundation did not screen Postings. Postings are the opinions of others and may or may not represent a commonly held view.

StudyBibleForum.com Copyright © The Lockman Foundation 2001-2016
Permission to quote guidelines.