Results 1 - 6 of 6
|
|
|||||
Results from: Answered Bible Questions, Answers, Unanswered Bible Questions, Notes Ordered by Verse | ||||||
Results | Verse | Author | ID# | |||
1 | Truth or Consequences | John 3:16 | Beja | 219815 | ||
Colton, you have stated that when you read scripture, your practice is to pray and see if it agrees with the Holy Spirit inside you. I would submit this scripture to you for you to pray over. 2 Timothy 3:14-17 You, however, continue in the things you have learned and become convinced of, knowing from whom you have learned them, and that from childhood you have known the sacred writings which are able to give you the wisdom that leads to salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for training in righteousness; so that the man of God may be adequate, equipped for every good work." I would ask you to ask a few questions as you pray over this passage. From where does it say that Timothy has learned the things he is sure of? Isn't it the sacred writings? Does this teach that all scripture is inspired? Or does it teach some of it is mixed with error? Where does this teach that we learn all the things we ought about walking in life as a Christian? In Christ, Beja |
||||||
2 | Inspired to Understand and Recognize | John 3:16 | coltonjunior | 219822 | ||
Did you read this part because it stands out like a sore thumb, I'm going to capitalize it not meaning to shout ""KNOWING FROM WHOM YOU HAVE LEARNED THEM, AND THAT FROM CHILDHOOD YOU HAVE KNOWN"" Now Beja, I know your counter-punch. You are going to tell me that Timothy was taught the scriptures during his childhood. When does infancy end and childhood begin? The interpretation I get from this passage is that Timothy already knew the truth that the sacred writings are saying. When Timothy read the sacred writings, it was a confirmation of the truth that was already in his heart. It was not a new discovery for Timothy. It was new in a sense that he recognized it for the first time, but it awakened something that was already in him at the time of his be taught the sacred writings. "ALL SCRIPTURES ARE INSPIRED BY GOD," but the inspiration to understand it and recognize it, that's an inspiration as well. You say Timothy learned everything from the sacred writings. I say it was already written in his mind and in his heart to understand and recognize the truth the sacred writings are talking about. (Ops, I sent this as a question, and I'm going to get banded from studybibleforum.com by the leaders of this sect. I will go back and send it as a note, sorry for the mistake.) | ||||||
3 | Inspired to Understand and Recognize | John 3:16 | Beja | 219823 | ||
I'm not sure I caught an answer in that. Perhaps you did, let me recap and see if I read you correctly. Timothy already knew it, and when he came to this scripture he found it to be true with what he already knew, or perhaps recognized it for the first time though its truth was already hidden in his heart? Is that correct? If that is correct then what you are saying is that what this passage says IS TRUE, and timothy recognized it as such. Therefore if the passage is true that has certain implications does it not? That means that the scriptures were inspired by God, is true. I disagree with you as to how Timothy came to it, but even if Timothy was recognizing a truth he already knew then it is still a truth, and it says something that we are affirming as true. And that something it is saying is that all scripture is true and trustworthy! If THAT is true, then we need not test all scripture by Holy Spirit given feelings, but we must rather try to understand it, knowing that a right reading of scripture yields trustworthy authoritative truth. Because that is the truth Timothy discovered, attested to, or found true, etc. In Christ Beja |
||||||
4 | Holy vs. Unholy | John 3:16 | coltonjunior | 219824 | ||
You and I are not that far from agreeing on this subject. The disagreement comes from how truth is recognized. I say yes, we do need to test all scripture by Holy Spirit Feelings, as you have stated. I apologize if you interpreted me saying the opposite, and I apologize if it seems as if I am contradicting myself. I don't mean to do so. Please help me to understand. If the Holy Spirit Feelings tells us it's true, then it is true, because the Holy Spirit Feelings tells us so. But everyone isn't guided by Holy Spirit Feelings such as you and I, so how do they recognize truth when it is presented to them? Do they blindly believe anything that it written, and/or do they have ""UNHOLY SPIRIT" feelings? | ||||||
5 | Holy vs. Unholy | John 3:16 | Beja | 219826 | ||
Scripture is true, because scripture is true. All scripture is true because all scripture is true. This is what it means when it says all scripture is inspired by God. The given, is that scripture is true. God's Holy Spirit does not affirm some scripture as true, and other scripture is not true. God's Holy Spirit confirms the truth of scripture in its entirety as a whole category. Now, that being said can scripture be preached wrongly, to where it misses what a passage was saying and therefore be preached wrongly? Absolutely. So, the way I'm going to take your question is as if you had said, "Given that scripture is true, how do we know we are interpreting it correctly?" First, the Holy Spirit does indeed guide us through this. As Paul says in 1st Corinthians spiritual things are indeed discerned by the guidance of the Spirit. Second though we know that scripture does not contradict itself. How do we know this? Because all scripture is inspired by God, and God is not going to give contradictory messages when they are rightly understood. So whenever we look at any single passage, we have every other scripture in the Bible to guide us in what it can be saying, because it is informed in light of them, and it can not be contradictory to any of them. So how do we know? We study it hard in light of scripture, we pray for guidance, and it is this which God will be present with to guide us to all truth. So what we are armed with for telling the truth of scripture is the scripture. In 1 John 4, John tells us that we are to test the spirits, because many false ones have gone out. What does this mean? It means, as you have stated, many have false spirits guiding their reading rather than the Holy Spirit. But how do we know which is leading us, Holy or false? John here says we are to know by whether it matches what we know and confess to be true, that Jesus is God in the flesh. Now, I do not think he means here to limit it only to that one test, God in flesh. Rather he is giving us an iron principle, that we test the spirtual guidance in us, by the truth of scripture. The Holy spirit will not lead us contrary to Christ and the apostles' teaching. So how this plays out, is that we constantly pray and test everything as to whether it matches scripture, and in the midst of this the Holy Spirit will guide us to do so. It does not guide us in a vacuum, it guides us as we interpret scripture with other scripture. In Christ, Beja |
||||||
6 | Holy vs. Unholy | John 3:16 | coltonjunior | 219829 | ||
... | ||||||