Bible Question:
Greetings Doc! You wrote: "Ed, the truth of a doctrine cannot be verified by the number of people who adhere to it. Just as the truth of a doctrine cannot be falsified by the number of people who abuse it. We need to carefully search the scriptures, and test the fruit of the adherents, as we are commanded." Yet, the arguement of this entire thread seems to be that very few have practiced it over the years; therefore, tongues must have passed away. :-) There is only one verse in the entire Bible that mentions the gift of tongues ceasing. That same verse also mentions prophesy and knowledge ceasing as well. The timing of this 'ceasing' is absolutely vague, to say the least. So, let's lay aside the historical arguement (which really carries no authority anyway), and address what Scripture actually says. What is your Scriptural case that tongues are no longer valid? Your Brother in Christ, Tim Moran |
Bible Answer: Hi, Brother Tim... very well said. I was talking about the history of tongues because that was Ed's topic. I will try to answer as clearly, openly, and honestly as possible. I do not have a clear scriptural basis to affirm that tongues are no longer valid. In fact, I am not certain of that conclusion, although I am open to its consideration. My doubt in the matter is really only circumstantial. As I stated earlier I do not find any conclusive evidence of a "private prayer language" in scripture. But that notion does appear to be frequently taught. Instead, I find in scripture that tongues always accompanied great evangelism. But that does not seem to be the case in circles where this doctrine is espoused. Throughout scripture any encounter with God always brings great conviction, humility, and a strong sense of His holiness. Every visitation of God polarizes people. Either they fall on their faces and cry out, "I am undone, have mercy on me!" (Isaiah 6:5, Luke 18:38) Or they rage, "We shall not walk therein, we have no king but Caesar!" (Jeremiah 6:16b, John 19:15b). If people are being touched so directly by the Holy Spirit such that tongues -- or any other signs -- are manifested as they claim, why is there not an equally strong desire for purity and holiness? I simply do not see those who adhere to this doctrine walking in greater obedience, or producing greater quantities of spiritual fruit, or even increasing in their love for one another. I especially do not see them growing in knowledge of the Holy Scriptures. My brothers, please do not think I am finding fault. I do not see myself as superior, for no doubt many who practice these doctrines are better men than I! Instead, I mourn at the absence of vital, scriptural spirituality. I hope that I have not drawn out this controversy. I wouldn't have answered your question if I had thought that I might be doing so. Thank you for your patience. |