☰ Menu
bible.lockman.org  Home | Search
 
  • Lockman.org
  • About Us

    • About
    • Who we are
    • History
    • Who is Jesus?
    •  
  • Shop / Catalog

    • Digital
    • NASB 2020
    • NASB 1995
    • NASB 1977
    • Amplified
    • NBLA (Spanish)
    • LBLA (Spanish)
    •  
  • NASB

    • NASB
    • Amplified
    • LBLA
    • NBLA
    • Permissions
    •  
Click Here
Bibles by the Case, with free shipping
All New NASB 2020 - 44% off
Save 40% or more on Bibles now! Limited quantities

Questions, answers, or notes on a Bible verse:
(i.e. Gen 1:1)
Read the Bible:
Book Chap:verse
New Window
Translation: Search Range: Search word(s):


Search for your Bible question and answer here:


Genesis

SCROLL TO BOTTOM FOR CONTENT THREADS.
Prior Chapter | Prior Verse | Next Verse | Next Chapter | Next Book | Viewing NASB and Amplified 2015
NASB Genesis 34:31 But they said, "Should he treat our sister as a harlot?"
AMPLIFIED 2015 Genesis 34:31 But they said, "Should he [be permitted to] treat our sister as a prostitute?"
SCROLL TO BOTTOM FOR CONTENT THREADS.
Subject:  Rape, Circumcission, Slaughter.

Bible Note:  "or did Dinah welcome the relationship and the "violence" was against Joseph's (and the brother's) property rights?"

Hi, JRM!

To read that Dinah was just being promiscuous and that the males felt violated because their property was taking without some form of agreement or payment, says very little for Jacob and his children! It is also contradicting the actions taken by Dinah's brothers... it would have been advantageous for them to have Dinah marry the prince--just imagine how much claut they would have with all the people that dealt with Shechem in the neighboring territories... instead, they have made a profound statement, one that places them in peril, as all the associates of the people they killed would, in the least, see Jacob and his family as adversaries!

I ask you to rethink your position and include the fact that Jacob was a servant of Yahweh and he and his family had a different set of standards (spiritual and moral) than those of Canaan and its neigboring terretories...

" am a little surprised about how comfortable you feel about the deceitful agreement re. circumcission. It seems to me like offering someone communion bread, but poisoning it first."

Yet, I am sure that you were not as surprised as I was when I read your suggestion about taking the money and marrying Dinah to her rapist! This is akin to discovering that someone removed a spare organ from your body and then offered you some cash for your troubles!

It seems that you exact a greater obligation on Jacob than you do on the pagans! Though I am not truly surprised as we witness this same treatment all over the world: those who have power are beyond any accountability--onless an example is required.

The violation, though it seems that you refuse to accept the fact that it took place, was both a physical (Dinah and her family) and a spiritual (Israel, the people of God) violation!:

1) Dinah's violation lead to Simeon's and Levi's deceitful retaliation on Shechem and his people (Geneisis 34:1-31) Simeon's and Levi's violence lead to Jacob's rejection of Simeon and Levi at his death bed (Genesis 49:5-7); 3) The sons of Levi, as Peter in John 21:15-18, were separated by Yahweh and redeemed from their father's violence (Exodus 32:26-28); 4) Jacob's rejection of Levi lead to the Tribe of Levi being dispersed amongst Insrael while their obedience to God's Command distinguished them for the service of the priestly tribe (Numbers 1:47-54; 3:12-13).

If you find fault at Simeon's, Levi's and Jacob's actions... is it because you truly do not find fault with Shechem and his people or is it because you do not understand God's Way?

The first Covenant involved temporal values (sinners were iradicated by means of a physical death); Israel (inclusive of Jacob and his children) lived under such Covenant!

God Bless!

Angel

  Up   |    Down     View Branch    ID# 135076  
 Questions and/or Subjects for Gen 34:31   Author 
 Rape, Circumcission, Slaughter. (?)
  Just Read Mark
 Hi, Just Read Mark! Have you noticed ...
  JCrichton
 Thanks for your thoughtful answer, espec...
  Just Read Mark
 "or did Dinah welcome the relationship ...
  JCrichton
 Perhaps Dinah was raped.  Horrible. How...
  Just Read Mark
 "This is true. As does our Maker." ...
  JCrichton
 Angel, I don't think my queries were pa...
  Just Read Mark
 Hi, JRM! I termed your interpretation...
  JCrichton
 Angel, I don't think my queries were pa...
  Just Read Mark
 Jacob's reaction to the slaughter. Tha...
  Just Read Mark
 Hi, JRM! This is exactly my point! ...
  JCrichton




bible.lockman.org
Answered Bible Questions
Primary Bible Questions (?)
Bible verses
About StudyBibleForum.com

The Lockman Foundation did not screen Postings. Postings are the opinions of others and may or may not represent a commonly held view.

StudyBibleForum.com Copyright © The Lockman Foundation 2001-2016
Permission to quote guidelines.