Results 1 - 4 of 4
|
|
|||||
Results from: Answered Bible Questions, Answers, Unanswered Bible Questions, Notes Ordered by Verse | ||||||
Results | Verse | Author | ID# | |||
1 | Advise on contradictions found in bible | Ps 25:4 | Benjibabs | 17548 | ||
Hi folks, Someone sent me the mail below, please advise on the supposed contradictions in the bible. Thanks. Benjibabs. These are some of the contradictions -or could be- that I found in the Holy Bible and I would really like to know why are they so? Sorry, I didn't type in the verses word for word but you can refer to them from your Bible. -------------------------- [Mathew 1:16] Joseph the carpenter is the son of Jacob. [Luke 3:23] Joseph the carpenter is the son of He'-li. ***************** [1 Corinthians 15:5] Jesus appeared to the twelve after he rose again. [Mathew 28:16] Jesus appeared to the eleven after he rose again. ****************** [Mathew 19:28] You which followed me in the regeneration, when the son of man shall sit in the throne of his glory, you shall also sit upon twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel. [John 6:70] Have I not chosen you twelve, and one of you is a DEVIL?! ******************* [John 8:14] If I bear record of myself, yet my record is true. [John 5:31] If I bear witness of myself, my witness is not true. ******************* [Luke 5:1] The story of the fishermen happened at the beginning of Jesus's mission. (See also Mathew 4:18) [John 21:1] The story of the fishermen happened after Jesus was resurrected from the dead. ******************** [Mathew 21:18] Jesus purified the temple from the sellers before he passed by the fig tree which he cursed. [Mark 11:12] Jesus purified the temple from the sellers after he passed by the fig tree which he cursed. ********************* [2 Samuel 24:1] God provoked David against Israel, and said: Go and number them. [1 Chronicles 21:1] Satan provoked David against Israel and ordered him to go and number Israel. ******************* [2 Samuel 10:18] David slew seven hundred chariots of the Syrians. [1 Chronicles 19:18] David slew seven thousand chariots of the Syrians. ******************* - Here are some of the contradictory narrations that I found about the crucifixion: [Mark 15:25] It was the third hour, and they crucified him. [John 19:14] It was the sixth hour, and he was not crucified yet. ******************* [Mathew 27:32] They compelled Simon to bear the cross of Jesus. (see also Luke 23:26 and Mark 15:21) [John 19:17] Jesus was bearing his cross himself. ******************** [Mark 15:21] They put Jesus on the cross. [1 Peter 2:24] They put Jesus on the tree. (See also Galatians 3:13) ******************** [Mark 15:23] They gave him wine mingled with myrrh to drink. [Mathew 7:34] They gave him vinegar mingled with gall to drink. ********************* [Mathew 27:44] The two thieves who were crucified with him were insulting him. [Luke 23:39] One of the thieves was reviling Jesus, and the other rebuked him saying: Do not you fear God?... And then he said to Jesus: Remember me when you come to your Kingdom. Jesus said to him, "Verily I say unto you, today you shall be with me in Paradise." ********************* [Mathew 27:5] Judas went and hanged himself. [Acts 1:18] Judas fell headlong, and burst asunder in the midst, and all his bowels gushed out. ********************** [John 20:1] The visitors to Jesus's grave: Mary Mag-da-le-ne only. [Mathew 28:1] Mary Mag-da-le-ne and another Mary. [Luke 24:10] Mary Mag-da-le-ne and another Mary and Jo'-an-na. [Mark 16:1] Mary Mag-da-le-ne3 and another Mary and Sa-lo'-me. *********************** [John 20:12] One woman saw two angels at the grave of Jesus. [Mathew 28:2] Two women saw one angel. [Luke 24:3] Three women saw two men. [Mark 16:5] Three women saw one man. ********************** [Luke 24:9] Mary the Mag-da-le-ne and Mary the mother of James and Jo'-an-na returned back from the grave and told the eleven apostles all of what they saw. [Mark 16:8] Mary Mag-da-le-ne and another Mary and Sa-lo'-me returned back from the grave and did not tell anyone anything because they were afraid. |
||||||
2 | Advise on contradictions found in bible | Ps 25:4 | Sir Pent | 17553 | ||
Dear Benjibabs, I appreciate that you are wanting to help the person who sent you these questions. I also believe that there are definite explanations for each of these "appearant contradictions". However, since there are so many of them, would you mind splitting this into several questions with only one or two "contradictions" in each one? I think that would help to keep the threads from getting overly long and complicated. I will share my thoughts on the first one about the lineage of Jesus' father Joseph. I have not studied this, but something just jumped out at me. I would guess that Jacob was Joseph's father and He'-li is Joseph's mother. If you look at those two geneologies, they both trace back to king David, but are completely different from there on. The Matthew account goes through king David's son Solomon. The Luke account goes through king David's son Nathan. I think the message that God has for us is that Jesus was a descendant of king David. In addition, it is interesting that this is true even in more than one branch of His family tree. |
||||||
3 | Advise on contradictions found in bible | Ps 25:4 | kalos | 17559 | ||
"He'-li is Joseph's *mother*"? Joseph was "the son of Heli" by marriage (Heli having no sons of his own). Joseph is the descendant of David. Mary is also the descendant of David. "Luke's entire section [of genealogy] from Joseph to David differs starkly from that given by Matthew. The two genealogies are easily reconciled if Luke's is seen as Mary's genealogy, and Matthew's version represents Joseph's. "Thus the royal line is passed through Jesus' legal father, and His physical descent from David is established by Mary's lineage... "Joseph was "the son of Heli" by marriage (Heli having no sons of his own), and thus is named in Luke 3:23 as the representative of Mary's generation. Moses himself established precedent for this sort of substitution in Numbers 27:1-11; 36:1-12" (pp. 1518-1519, MacArthur Study Bible, 1997, Word). |
||||||
4 | Advise on contradictions found in bible | Ps 25:4 | Sir Pent | 17586 | ||
Dear Kalos, Thank you for this additional perspecitive. I think that this could quite possibly be correct. I would think that if one geneology is that of Joeseph and the other is of Mary, then it would be the other way around. I would think that Heli would be Joseph's father, and Jacob would be Joseph's father-in-law. My reasoning is that the geneology in Matthew, which includes Jacob, also includes several women. It mentions the names of Rahab (Salmon's wife), Ruth (Boaz' wife), and Mary (Joeseph's wife). I would assume that having a more feminine leaning, that this would be the geneology of Mary (or Joseph's in-laws). On the other hand the geneology in Luke (which includes Heli) only mentions Salmon, Boaz, and Joeseph. Therefore, I would think that it would make more sense that this would be Joeseph's direct lineage. As I said in my first response, I have not studied this in great length. This is just what seems to make the most sense to me based purely on the biblical passages in question. |
||||||